Thankfully that’s the international break interruptions out of the way until March, and we can get back to focusing on the vastly more important business of Orient. In the absence of very much going on in Orientland, I thought it might be interesting to take stock of how the 2026/27 has gone so far. A Quarter-Term Review if you like.
Goalkeepers
Having our own permanent goalkeeper for the first time since Lawrence Vigouroux departed in the summer of 2023, has to be seen as a positive. For the most part, Nathan Baxter has looked a solid shot-stopper and competent in dealing with balls into the box. His distribution, most specifically his kicking, is somewhat questionable however. Still, 6 cleans sheets and 12 goals conceded in 13 appearances represents a decent enough start to his time with Orient.
Bringing in a young keeper on loan with the reputation of Oliver Dovin as back-up, or even to challenge Baxter for a starting spot, seemed like a very shrewd move. However, the Orient keeper curse struck again, and it looks highly unlikely that we will see him add to his solitary appearance in the EFL Trophy for us.
Signing Dovin seemed to be very much about allowing Noah Phillips to gain experience out on loan. But after a brief spell at Gateshead, he is back at Brisbane Road as the number 2 to Baxter. Phillips very much impressed in his early season appearances but looked a bit shaky (didn’t the whole team?) in his last outing at Barnet.
Killian Cahill remains on the books, but Richie has made it clear that barring an emergency (never say never with regard to Orient’s goalkeepers!) he won’t be in the team.
Grade: C-
Decent enough if Baxter remains available, but if he is to miss any significant amount of time, (yet another!) goalkeeping addition might be required.
_________________________________
Defence
We don’t know for sure, but if I were to hazard a guess, I would suggest that going into the season Richie Wellens wanted to play a back four, with his first-choice quartet being: Fin Stevens. Joseph Olowu, Will Forrester and Somto Boniface. Injuries, specifically to Boniface on the first day of the season, Forrester, and more recent Olowu have meant that he has been unable to field those four together at any point during the campaign. We have also seen him switching to three centre backs for several matches in response to the number of goals we shipped in the early part of the season.
While Stevens has been an absolute rock of consistency throughout the start to the season at both right back and centre back, and young Phil Chinedu has impressed when asked to step into the centre of the defence, if less so at left back/ wingback; it is fair to say that James Morris is still recovering from his nightmare cameo against Sheffield Wednesday in the opening match of the campaign.
In the early games Olowu always looked like he had a mistake in him, he then seemed to settle down until his enforced absence after being concussed at Reading. The return to fitness of both Alfie Gilchrist and, quite spectacularly, REG have been timely, and the gaffer now actually has some choices to make in picking his defence ahead of tomorrow’s match against Wimbledon.
Somewhat surprisingly, we are tied for fifth place for the fewest goals conceded in the division (14) with Sheffield Wednesday and Notts County. That is more impressive when you remember that we conceded 8 of those in our opening 3 home league games.
Grade: C+
Having all our defenders fit and being able to enjoy consistency in selection should help us to tighten up further at the back.
_________________________________
Midfield
A midfield three of: Isaac Hayden, Idris El Mizouni and Alex Gilbert should be the envy of the third tier, but I can’t be the only one that is feeling a bit underwhelmed so far.
Perhaps I was expecting a bit too much of Hayden based on his experience in the Premier League. But I was hoping for someone to provide security in front of the defence, as well as the drive from the centre of the park that has been missing since Darren Pratley retired and Jordan Brown departed. Similarly, when the team has been struggling and look for someone to provide leadership, I am not sure the former Newcastle man has always pushed himself to the fore.
El Mizouni’s disappointing start to the season led to him being unceremoniously dropped for a couple of matches after the loss at home to Plymouth. Wellens suggesting that it was to give the Tunisian a needed kick up the backside. Since then, El Miz has looked much more like the player that we all know he is.
Obviously, no one in their right mind would turn down a player of the quality of Alex Gilbert when he is out of contract and available on a free transfer, but personally I remain to be convinced that his recruitment wasn’t more opportune than part of our recruitment plan. The balance of the midfield has looked better when Gilbert and El Miz have operated as a pair with a number 10 in front of them, rather than as a three with Hayden. The long-term absence of Ollie O’Neill perhaps means that we might need to revisit that, but getting the right configuration in the engine room has to be a priority going forward.
Grade: D
We haven’t, as yet, found the right selection in midfield to benefit the team as a whole, despite the talent at our disposal. Getting that right going forward is a must.
_________________________________
Attack
Trying to replace a striker of the quality of Dom Ballard, whose goals unquestionably kept us in League 1 last season, was always going to be a huge, if not impossible, challenge. Especially given that our other very capable goalscorer, Aaron Connolly, was still recovering from injury and wouldn’t be available for the first month and a half of the season.
Jaze Kabia is stepping up a division and has struggled a bit with the physicality needed at this level, but his return of 5 goals from 13 league appearances feels very much par for the course in terms of expectation.
The same cannot be said of Dane Scarlett unfortunately. The former Spurs academy player arrived with a big reputation, and while we know that he needed to get up to speed fitness-wise, having not had a proper pre-season, he has struggled to make any discernible impact. There has been the odd flash here and there that suggests we might have a quality striker on our hands, but for me the jury remains very much out.
Yusuf Akhamrich started the season like a house on fire, much as he did at Bristol Rovers in League 2 last year. However, as teams have started to work him out, his impact has been greatly reduced, so much so that he has dropped out of the side recently.
Armando Dobra struggled for game time initially, but over recent weeks seems very much to have forced his way into the team on the left flank. Such has been his impact that Connolly has been moved to his less preferred position on the right. Unless Dobra is utilised as a number 10, then it seems our front three is pretty much set, subject to availability of course.
Grade: D-
Recent performances have hinted at more to come from a settled forward line, but it needs to start happening soon and on a consistent basis.
_________________________________
Management
The backing he has received from the Board, combined with the recruitment work that he and new Director of Football, Scott Mitchell, did in the summer have left Richie Wellens with nowhere to go and no one to blame if things don’t go to plan again this season.
With 16 new players coming in it will obviously take time for the squad to gel. Injuries haven’t helped, but we are only now beginning to get an indication of what Wellens’ first choice eleven is and the formation to get the best out of them. The comments about fans’ expectations and, more recently, about the players’ attitude and work rate were concerning, as they suggested that Wellens knows he’s under pressure to deliver again this season.
Grade: C-
Our best seasons in League 1 have come with a drastic improvement in form from the autumn. That didn’t happen last season, but there have been some positive signs in recent performances. The next run of games will be critical: go on a good run and the momentum will build, continue to be up and down and the fears of a repeat of 2025/26 will only grow.
_________________________________
Up the O’s!